The Informed SLP Logo
JobsHow to Hire and Recruit SLPsWhy your Gen Z employees won't just try (and where you're wrong about that)

Why your Gen Z employees won't just try (and where you're wrong about that)

Trying without training is hard for everyone today. Learn why it's not just generational, and what to do about it.

It’s a common thing we see managers and owners say about their newest SLP hires:

  • “What’s up with this younger generation?”
  • “They expect to be trained on every single thing, and won’t just try to problem-solve.”
  • “They expect all the answers to be right there.”

 

… and when lots of people say the same thing, the perception probably isn’t nothing. But let’s also look at what it might be, and what could be done about it as an employer. Because ultimately, when you hire, you’re hiring for work to get done—not for months and months of training before that person can start taking on billable hours. So let’s go through how to solve it!

 

Generational differences and avoidance

 

“I don’t know how to do that.”

“Nobody taught me how to x, y, z.”

“Grad school taught me nothing.”

 

Sound familiar? But before you say—“Well me neither—figure it out!” (do not do that), it’s important to realize that observing generational differences is often related to the fact that we were all raised, and continue to exist inside, different circumstances. Many of which are contradictory, and difficult to make sense of.

For example research surveys show that 80% of Gen Z believe that embracing failure makes them more innovative, and say that they’re energized by new challenges. However, managers working with this same cohort consistently report the opposite: people who regularly freeze rather than try.

 

And the thing is—both can be true. Employees (Gen Z or not) can know in their minds that failure produces resilience, and better learning. They can name it and verbalize it. But doing it is something different, because that requires safety.

 

Failing in front of a brand-new boss is a huge risk. Failing in front of a boss that you worry may fire you is a huge risk. Failing when the workplace and job market simply aren’t as safe today as it was for those of us who built our careers in the 80s, 90s, and early 2000s, is worth noticing.

 

This is also why you’ll see this same “Gen Z” behavior in elder-millennial employees as well—it’s because everyone is just… a little nervous and on edge, to say the least. But it’s important you don’t label these things as “no grit” or “low resilience” or “lazy”, because a lot of this is a natural defense mechanism based on the environment, rather than a widespread generational character flaw.

 

And it’s not just today that’s different, but the background of many of your employees is different than it used to be. A couple hypotheses you’ll see floating around:

 

  • Less unstructured practice than previous generations. Many of today’s workforce grew up with heavily scheduled, adult-supervised childhoods and far less unsupervised trial-and-error than earlier generations.
  • Failures are public and permanent. Everything these days has photographic and timeline evidence. Misspeaking on something gets you cancelled. Schools have emphasized getting the answer right over attempting hard things. In this environment, saying "I don't know how" is safe. And in a work context, transfers risk and responsibility to the employer, and in that regard is a rational move to avoid risk.
  • It’s not the generation; it’s everyone. Older folks saying “younger folks aren’t doing this right” is a tale as old as time. But fear of failure crosses generations, and includes today’s entrepreneurs as well as employees.

 

 

Might it be management? Is it me?

 

Yeah, it probably is you, at least a little bit. Because unless you’re having hard conversations very regularly, it’s just as likely to be a management skill gap as it is an failure to launch by the employee. Less than half of people who supervise people were actually trained on how to supervise. That’s a whole other conversations for another day, but here’s a good podcast and here’s a good social media follow for now.

 

But the point is—fear of trying hard things, and failure, aren’t isolated to people with less power in the workforce dynamic. You just might not have the supervisory feedback to see how it impacts your performance as a boss, too.

 

And then sometimes it’s a budget and org problem! Because hiring without leaving adequate time or budget for training or management can also be the problem. It’s not always that employees are expecting too much training; sometimes they’re not getting enough of the bare-minimum.

 

 

So what now? How to solve this today

 

You already have the employee hired. You want this to work. And a blog post that tells you “this is a problem everywhere, and you’re likely also part of the problem…” helps with long-term problem solving but doesn’t give you the short-term fixes. So here are some fixes!

 

1) Be a person who is safe to fail in front of. You’re going to have to have some hard conversations. They need to be clear, direct, and focused on how it’s ok to try and fail, and what the consequences would actually look like. Don’t make false promises about safety that doesn’t exist; but also show that you, as a boss, have left room for failure without that being a problem. Attempting has to feel safer than not attempting, and the boss has most leverage to create that feeling of safety.

 

2) Make the attempt (not the result) the thing that counts. Make it very clear that your number one priority is trying, not doing therapy perfectly. Then, focus on rewarding the attempts before you move on to making the attempts gradually better. Make sure to talk to your employees about how long it takes to get “good” (often several years!)

 

3) Don’t accept “I don’t know” or “I can’t”. Instead, help them take the next steps, which will look a lot like, “What’s your best guess at the first step?” or “If you had to just do it anyway, what could you try first?” or “Where would you look to get more information to make this decision?” and similar. Don’t fill the silence and don’t give the answers—simply guide them through it, without making it feel like a quiz. Then show them that they were the one driving, and creating the success, the whole time.

 

4) Be clear about what the job is. Write down which parts are required (in order to be paid, or stay employed) and which parts are optional. Provide some flexibility—let your employees do less if they need to, but be clear about how that comes with being paid less until they’re ready for more.

 

5) Celebrate learning and steps toward success, rather than perfect success alone. Help your employees take pride and delight in the journey, the same way you likely have had to do within your own career.

 

6) Finally, don’t get too hung up on generational differences. Generations are all different, and there will be trends. But people are also all different. You’ll see behaviors cross generations, and expect for many people to surprise you. We put “Gen Z employees” in the title just because it it’s what employers often say and want to talk about. But the more you learn, the less that phrase will likely be your default.

 

Proceed with empathy, open conversations, and know that it’s hard for everyone—employers and employees!

 

 

Employer 1.png